Horsemen's Den
6.5.25
2025 Draft Grades & Recap
First things first—I vote to keep the draft
online moving forward, but let’s push it back to August
1st to allow for clearer depth
charts and preseason buzz.
Goats
Grade: A-
Pulled a fast one on Bill by
trading up with zero intention
of drafting Josh Allen—respect. Landed four
starters: Barkley, Sutton, Warren, and Sanders.
Blue might even get a shot at RB in Dallas. Only
reason for the slight downgrade? Jordan
Love was traded for a much better package than
you got for him – huge miss.
Co’s Pro’s
Grade: A
Jeanty is a steal—if he had
played at Georgia or Texas, people would be
calling him the next Marshall Faulk. Harvey
could become the next Kamara under Sean Payton.
Not personally sold on DJ Moore, but still a
strong pick. Also, loading up on TEs—do you know
something we don’t? Rule change coming?
Bohemians
Grade: B+
Got outmaneuvered by Oat in
the trade-up… let that sink in. That said,
landing a top-3 QB for the next 7 years is huge,
but I give Bill 3.5 years before he trades Josh.
I was trying to trade up to get Josh myself.
Johnson in Pittsburgh is a smart play—he’ll get
volume. Loveland and Harris should both be
starters.
Goodfellas
Grade: D
Limited draft capital. Kirk
is crashing faster than you guys at the rest
stop. Finnan has potential… in 2026.
Buffalo 66
Grade: B
Hampton and Hunter are true
wildcards—both could boom or bust. Hampton
especially has a high upside. But Hunter in
Jacksonville? Not loving it—especially with that
overhyped QB.
Incubus
Grade: B-
Baker in Tampa with those
weapons is a great for fantasy football numbers.
Pro tip: start him every week except his bye.
Goedert has one year left, and the rest of the
draft was pretty forgettable.
Terry Schiavos
Grade: B
Now wearing the “fair and
equitable” crown in trade talks. Loaded up for a
strong EO25 run with Metcalf, Brown, and
Hockenson. Good move acquiring Jordan Love. Lou
who?
TBD
Grade: B-
No immediate starters for
2025, but Henderson, Williams, and Sanders
should contribute in 2026. Keep an eye on Fidone—he
could be a sleeper at TE.
Utter Dominance
Grade: B
Tom was thrilled to land
Lamar Jackson—momentarily. The excitement faded,
and the rest of the draft fizzled. And Ridley?
Bum status confirmed.
Cellmates
Grade: B-
Outside of Judkins, not much
to love. What’s the plan with all the QBs you
drafted?
Horsemen
Grade: C+
Went all in last year when I
shouldn’t have—but rebuilt the WR room and
snagged what could be a steal on Atlanta’s
offensive line. Run, Penix, run! The extra 2026
picks should help the rebuild take shape or
redraft the EO25 players I traded.
DDR
Grade: A
Might have landed the top
rookie WR and a
TE in Taylor who will be Fields’ favorite
check-down option. Quietly had a great draft.
Gamblers
Grade: C+
Dart could be a home run or
a complete bust. If the Giants move on from
their coaching staff, Dart may be toast. The
Samuel pick? Bold, if nothing else.